Outraged for black womanhood
After a lifetime in Caribbean and international politics, I thought the time had long since passed when I could be outraged by any event. But I was outraged last week, and I continue to seethe over the fact that Pamela Ramsey Taylor — the director of a Clay County, West Virginia, non-profit who was removed from her post after she called Michelle Obama an “ape in heels” in a November Facebook post — will be reinstated in her job on December 23. What signal does this reinstatement send to Americans, black and white? Indeed, what statement does it make to the rest of the world?
This is not only blatant racism getting a pass, it is a most disturbing endorsement of it!
Worse yet, it is a savage attack on black womanhood — something to which every right-minded person anywhere in the world should respond with robust indignation. I would not have been comfortable with myself if, through this commentary, I did not record my anger that Taylor’s crass and vulgar remark has been rewarded. That reward opens wide the door to similar — if not worse — assaults on the dignity of black women.
Arguably, black women have been denigrated and degraded more than any other race of women in history and the world. In the Americas, including the Caribbean, they have been owned, abused, violated, and discounted by white men and white women alike. For centuries, in slavery, they did not own their own bodies, nor could they claim their own children. Their maltreatment did not end with slavery. In the post-Emancipation period, they were denied education, training, and the vote, even as these rights were reluctantly granted to black men. In modern times, they struggle for equal pay with men, and for access to jobs for which they are as qualified as any man, black or white.
Michelle Obama epitomises the finest qualities of womanhood. She overcame all the prejudices and bigotry endemic in the society into which she was born to attend premier US institutions, graduating from Princeton University (cum laude in 1985) and Harvard Law School in 1988. She worked for a leading law firm in Chicago. And, if her academic and professional accomplishments are not more than sufficient to earn her respect and admiration, she is physically an extremely attractive woman who carries herself with immense grace and charm.
Perhaps it is that attractiveness — acknowledged worldwide by kings and queens and celebrated fashion houses as much as ordinary folk — that caused Taylor to describe this fine representative of all women (not just black women) as an “ape in heels”. For those in whom racial superiority is ingrained, the very notion that a black woman could be regarded as bright, beautiful, and regal challenges their atavistic and visceral sense of superiority and, with it, their power.
The “ape in heels” remark was as much an expression of a desire to repress black people as contenders for a place equal to white people, as it was a spewing of vexation that this particular woman is a shining example to others who might be emboldened to follow in her footsteps.
Much has been written about the presidency of Barack Obama. Not so much has been written of Michelle. But the dignity, decency and respect for the Obama White House was not his doing alone. The Obama family is among the very best of American presidential families (all of whom hitherto have been white), and that is due as much to Michelle Obama as to Barack Obama. Their performance is summed up in the phrase that will be associated with her eternally: “When they go low, we go high.” What she clearly meant is that, despite the racial slurs and the unprecedented public abuse thrown at her husband — the twice-elected president — they operated in the White House consistent with their roles as the representatives of all the people of the United States.
The racist elements in the United States (and in other parts of the world) were never content with a black president or a black first lady, both of whom captured the imagination and respect of people the world over. That acceptance and acclaim does not play well with their characterisation of the black race as inferior, or their own sense of ownership of the levers of power.
When Taylor said that she would be pleased to see “a white woman” again in the White House, she was asserting relief that whites could be seen again to be fully in charge. The flip side of that contention is that blacks would be returned to their place — and that place does not include the highest office in the land, or occupancy of the “White” House.
Michelle Obama never responded to Taylor’s remarks. She did not dignify them. She did the right thing. But the Government of West Virginia did the wrong thing by reinstating Taylor to her job. She now has a licence to continue to be vicious, and others will feel they have a free pass to denigrate black people.
In all this, the words of the late Maya Angelou, articulating the resolve of black women, in particular, to overcome dance through my mind:
“You may write me down in history
With your bitter, twisted lies,
You may tread me in the very dirt
But still, like dust, I’ll rise.”
The Obamas triumphed in the White House and showed the world that the depiction of black people — and particularly black women — is distorted. The Obamas in the White House ripped that depiction to shreds. In no small way, that is due to a most attractive woman who walked as gracefully in her heels as she sparkled in her running shoes, and even barefooted.
Every woman should be pleased that Michelle Obama represented and empowered them.
Sir Ronald Sanders is Antigua and Barbuda’s ambassador to the US and Organisation of American States; an international affairs consultant; as well as senior fellow at Massey College, University of Toronto, and the Institute of Commonwealth Studies, University of London. He previously served as ambassador to the European Union and the World Trade Organization and as high commissioner to the UK. The views expressed are his own. For responses and to view previous commentaries: